I'm only a moderate fan of Peeps. I know that Peeps have their detractors, and their lovers. I fall somewhere in the middle of the spectrum.
I'm Peep-friendly, if you will. Marshmallow-curious. Every year at Easter I'll buy one pack of Peeps, eat them , enjoy them, and call it good for the year.
I usually eat my Peeps fresh, although I understand the appeal of the stale Peep. Many people feel that Peeps need to be ripened for a few days (or weeks) before they can be eaten. I feel the same way about Red Vines. So I can empathize with this point of view.